Contradictory Reports
There are many conflicting reports regarding the wherabouts of the Mombai Shluchim. The Indian newspaper "Economic Times" is reporting that the worst has happened to Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg, and his wife Rivka. The newspaper is considered credible by most, but we hope that the information is erroneous. In a phone conversation with a family member, he denied the reports, "there are all sorts of rumors circulating, if there's news the family would be the first to know" he informed Chabad.info. We have so far been unable to confirm the story, as there is no other source for this report.
Chabad.info
29 Cheshvan 5769 (27.11.2008)
The Economic Times: Rabbi, wife killed in attack on Rabbi, wife killed in attack on Jewish centre


28 Nov 2008, 0219 hrs IST,


MUMBAI: Till Thursday morning, Nariman House and its occupants at Colaba were not exactly well known. But as Mumbaikars watched the night of horror unfold, little-known Nariman Bhavan was the scene of a raging gunbattle between terrorists and security personnel, thanks personnel, thanks to its Jewish occupants.

The building, along with the far better known Taj Palace and Oberoi hotels, found itself under siege. The terrorists took a young Israeli Rabbi Gavriel Holtzberg and his young wife Rivka staying at Nariman Bhavan hostage. Both were reportedly killed. The terrorists, however, spared their two-year old son and a maid.

The building is well known as an address for Chabad — pronounced Habaad — a kind of rendezvous for Israeli tourists visiting Mumbai. Besides being a meeting point, it also serves as a tourist information centre and offers shelter to visiting Israelis.

For conservative Jews, it’s the only place in the vicinity that serves Kosher food. According to sources about six terrorists are still in the building, as the operation to flush them was still ongoing at the time this article was written.

The Israeli embassy in New Delhi refused to furnish details about the number of its citizens trapped inside Chabad House. It said it is waiting for the security operation to end. According to Chabad website, the group has 13 centres across India. 
   




1.

His mother says he is alive and not concious


2. if it's not %100 true!
don't put such a headline!!
is this true or not?!


3. news report
yehudise
WHY IN THE WORLD DO YOU PRINT SUCH TERRIBLE NEWS IF YOU ARE NOT A MILLION PERCENT SURE IT'S TRUE?! THE SATAN DOESN'T NEED OUR HELP. MAYBE I'M BEING UNREALISTIC BUT LET'S HOPE THAT TONIGHT WILL ALSO BE A CHAG HAGEULAH FOR THIS YOUNG SHLUCIM COUPLE.


4. Tracht Gut Vet Zain Gut

Think Good and it will be Good! Daven, give extra Tzedakah and think positively. Don't make false assumptions!


5.

I am sure he is alive, unlike this unsure & false report.


6.

why put this on if not sure???

tracht gut ES VET ZEIN GUT


7. Put R"L
Mottel
Are you just a media outlet? What is your purpose? If it is holy and good, if you have to put such words at least write "R'L" in fact don't write it at all, don't panic everyone, verify your sources first


8.

what is the latest info.......




9.

I looked at the economist times website. I didn't see this report there!


10.
same as #7
Also it is economIC times not economIST times


11.

they are surly ALIVE,sheliach mitzva dont get harmed


12. Chevre, Tracht Gut!




13. NOT TRUE
david
This is an unreliable resource!!

They have a bias, for sure.

by publishing such a horrible thing, they get hits on their website


14.

TEHILLIM NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SOLDIERS GOING INTO CHABAD HOUSE NOW!!!!!



15.

"Two to three terrorists are still inside Nariman House but there are no more hostages inside."

http://www.ndtv.com/convergence/ndtv/story.aspx?id=NEWEN20080074405&ch=11/28/2008%207:20:00%20AM


16.

think good and it will be good-it helps!


17. PLEASE NEVER WRITE BAD NEWS UNLESS 100,000,000 PERCENT CORRECT
fan of chabad.info
Rosh Chodesh Keslaiv let us all dance and rejoice because Moshiach is Here!!!





Light edition - for saving-as ...